← Home
Quality Control · Troubleshooting Library

WELD DEFECTS

Every weld discontinuity has a cause — and nearly every cause can be traced back to a process, a parameter, a consumable, or a technique. This library teaches you to diagnose the weld in front of you: symptom to discontinuity, mechanism to cause, cause to correction.

Think Like a Troubleshooter

THE DIAGNOSIS PATH

1. OBSERVE

Look at the weld. Name what you see — a hole, a groove, a crack.

2. IDENTIFY

Classify the discontinuity. Porosity? Undercut? Lack of fusion?

3. MECHANISM

Understand how it formed — gas trapped, arc melting, shrinkage.

4. CAUSE

Trace the mechanism to a controllable variable.

5. CORRECT

Change the variable — parameter, consumable, technique, prep.

6. VERIFY

Re-inspect. Confirm the defect is gone before the next weld.

The Rule That Saves Time

Never change three variables at once. Change one, weld, inspect. When the defect disappears, you found the cause. If you change everything, you learn nothing.

The Basics

DISCONTINUITY OR DEFECT?

Discontinuity

Any interruption in the expected structure of a weld — a pore, a toe notch, a slightly convex bead. Nearly every weld contains small discontinuities. Most are harmless. Discontinuity is a description of what exists, not a verdict on whether it matters.

Defect

A discontinuity that the applicable code, specification, or service condition deems unacceptable — large enough, located badly enough, or present in a weld that cannot tolerate it. The same discontinuity can be a defect under one code and perfectly acceptable under another.

Why This Distinction Matters

Rejecting welds that the code accepts costs time and money. Accepting welds the code rejects costs your reputation and the structure. The governing document — not a gut feeling — draws the line. See the full treatment in Weld Discontinuity vs Defect.

Classification

WHY WELD DEFECTS OCCUR

Surface vs Internal

Surface defects — undercut, overlap, arc strikes, spatter, surface porosity — are visible to the eye. Internal defects — lack of fusion, slag inclusion, internal porosity, lamellar tearing — hide inside the joint and need NDT to find.

Process-Related

Every process has its signature defects: tungsten inclusions belong to TIG and plasma, slag inclusions to stick and FCAW, worm tracks to FCAW, incomplete penetration to any open-root weld.

Material & Metallurgy

Hydrogen cracking, hot cracking, and lamellar tearing live here — driven by steel chemistry, restraint, cooling rate, and through-thickness ductility, not by what the welder dials in.

Equipment & Consumables

Worn contact tips, damp electrodes, wrong tungsten, leaking gas hoses, dirty liners — the hardware between the machine and the arc causes a long list of defects.

Parameter & Technique

Current, voltage, travel speed, stick-out, angle, weave — the welder's inputs. Undercut, overlap, burn-through, and profile defects almost always trace back here.

Environment

Wind stripping shielding gas, cold base metal, humidity in electrodes, wet joints — the shop conditions that turn good parameters into bad welds.

How Defects Are Found

INSPECTION METHODS

Method Finds Best For
VT — VisualUndercut, overlap, arc strikes, spatter, crater, surface cracks, profileEvery weld, first and always
PT — PenetrantFine surface cracks, surface porosityNon-magnetic metals (aluminum, stainless)
MT — Magnetic ParticleFine surface and near-surface cracksCarbon and low-alloy steel
UT — UltrasonicLack of fusion, slag, internal cracks, incomplete penetrationThick sections, in-service inspection
RT — RadiographicInternal porosity, slag, lack of fusion, cracksPressure vessels, pipe, critical structural
DimensionalProfile, reinforcement height, fillet size, distortionFit-up and final acceptance checks
Acceptance Is Code-Dependent

Every defect page in this library frames acceptance the same way: the limits live in the governing document — AWS D1.1 for structural steel, ISO 5817 for fusion welds, API 1104 for pipelines, plus project specifications. Read the code that applies to your job.

The Library

BROWSE ALL DEFECTS

17 references, organized by severity. Each page covers identification, mechanism, prevention, correction, process-specific causes, parameters, equipment, inspection, and FAQs.

CRITICAL

HIGH

MEDIUM

LOW

CONCEPT

Connected Knowledge

THE DEFECT IS A SIGNAL

Every defect points back to a process, a machine, or a number. Follow the trail.

THE PROCESSES

Each defect page names the processes that produce it — and links to the full process references.

THE NUMBERS

Most defects are a parameter problem. The calculators turn a suspicion into a number.

THE GUIDES

The fundamentals that stop defects before they start.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

The questions welders ask before they open a defect page.

What is the difference between a weld discontinuity and a weld defect?

A discontinuity is any interruption in the weld's expected structure. It becomes a defect only when the applicable code, specification, or service condition says it exceeds the acceptable limit. The same discontinuity can pass one code and fail another.

What is the most common weld defect?

Porosity — usually from contamination, low gas flow, wrong stick-out, or damp consumables. It is also one of the easiest to eliminate with a systematic gas-and-cleanliness check.

What is the most serious weld defect?

Cracking — hot, hydrogen, and lamellar — because cracks grow under load. Hydrogen cracking can appear hours after welding, which is why preheat and low-hydrogen practice matter on high-strength steel.

How are weld defects found?

Visual inspection (VT) for surface indications; penetrant (PT) and magnetic particle (MT) for fine surface cracks; ultrasonic (UT) and radiography (RT) for internal indications. The code decides which method applies to which weld.

Can a weld defect always be repaired?

Most can — excavate to sound metal and re-weld to a qualified procedure. Codes usually limit the number and size of repairs. Some defects are not repairable at all, which is why prevention is the real fix.